Neighborhood guides
Where to live around Milwaukee.
Ten communities we know well, from city neighborhoods on the lake to Waukesha County suburbs. Each guide covers housing styles, schools, parks, what to check before you buy and who it fits.
Wauwatosa
Tosa. Historic downtown on the Menomonee River, tree-lined blocks and the Milwaukee Regional Medical Center.
Read the guide Waukesha CountyBrookfield
Established suburban streets, larger lots, Elmbrook schools and easy access to I-94.
Read the guide MilwaukeeBay View
South side lakefront neighborhood with its own personality, from KK to the bluffs.
Read the guide Waukesha CountyMenomonee Falls
Wisconsin's largest village, with a wide mix of homes, its own school district and big local employers.
Read the guide North ShoreWhitefish Bay
Classic North Shore village on Lake Michigan, with walkable blocks and highly rated schools.
Read the guide MilwaukeeEast Side
City living between the river and the lake, near Brady Street, UWM and Lake Park.
Read the guide Waukesha CountyWaukesha
The county seat, with a historic downtown on the Fox River and neighborhoods at many price points.
Read the guide Waukesha CountyNew Berlin
Popular suburban alternative with room to spread out, lots of parks and two highways nearby.
Read the guide North ShoreShorewood
Compact lakefront village between the East Side and Whitefish Bay, walkable and dense.
Read the guide Waukesha CountyPewaukee
Lake life on Pewaukee Lake with a suburban pace and one campus for all its schools.
Read the guideHow to pick the right community
Start with the four things that usually decide it: your commute, your budget, the kind of house you want, and schools. Then think about how you like to spend free time, whether that's walking to dinner, being near the lake, or having a big yard.
- Want to walk everywhere? Look at the East Side, Shorewood, Bay View and the Village area of Wauwatosa.
- Schools are the priority? Compare Whitefish Bay, Brookfield, Shorewood, Wauwatosa and Pewaukee, and confirm boundaries for each address.
- More space for the money? Look at New Berlin, Menomonee Falls and Waukesha.
- Lake life? Pewaukee Lake in Pewaukee, or Lake Michigan in Bay View, the East Side, Shorewood and Whitefish Bay.
- Duplex to live in and rent out? Bay View and the East Side have the most two-unit homes.
Milwaukee County vs Waukesha County
Milwaukee County includes the City of Milwaukee and inner suburbs like Wauwatosa, Shorewood and Whitefish Bay. Homes there are generally older and closer to downtown, and many neighborhoods are walkable. Waukesha County, to the west, includes Brookfield, New Berlin, Pewaukee, Menomonee Falls and the City of Waukesha. Homes are generally newer, lots are bigger, and most people drive for errands.
Property tax rates differ by municipality and school district on both sides of the county line, so we compare actual tax bills for the homes you're considering instead of relying on averages.
What homes cost
Prices vary a lot within each community, from condos and starter homes to large historic homes and lakefront properties. Averages go stale fast and hide those differences, so we pull current closed sales from the MLS for the exact areas and home types you're considering. Ask us and we'll send them over.
Side by side
Compare the communities
| Community | County | Schools | Often a fit for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wauwatosa | Milwaukee County | Wauwatosa School District, East and West high schools | People working at the Medical Center |
| Brookfield | Waukesha County | Mostly Elmbrook School District; a small southwest part is Waukesha | Families focused on Elmbrook schools |
| Bay View | City of Milwaukee | Milwaukee Public Schools, plus citywide choice options | Buyers who want city living near the lake |
| Menomonee Falls | Waukesha County | Menomonee Falls School District; southwest areas in Hamilton | First-time buyers who want a suburb with options |
| Whitefish Bay | Milwaukee County | Whitefish Bay School District, one high school | Families focused on schools |
| East Side | City of Milwaukee | Milwaukee Public Schools | Buyers who want walkable city living by the lake |
| Waukesha | Waukesha County (county seat) | School District of Waukesha: North, South and West high schools | First-time buyers who want options in Waukesha County |
| New Berlin | Waukesha County | School District of New Berlin: Eisenhower and West | Buyers who want more space for the money |
| Shorewood | Milwaukee County | Shorewood School District, one high school | Buyers who want to walk everywhere |
| Pewaukee | Waukesha County | Pewaukee School District, all on one campus | Buyers who want lake life without going far from Milwaukee |
Not sure which one fits?
Tell us your budget, commute and must-haves. We'll put a few communities side by side for you.